Preview: Michigan at Indiana

Preview: Michigan at Indiana

October 1, 2010
Expect to see a lot of this: Indiana quarterback Ben Chappell picking
on Michigan’s secondary.

Rush Offense vs. Indiana Rush Defense
Michigan is currently the #2 rushing offense in the country with 331.25 yards a game.  Meanwhile, Indiana has been giving up 177 yards a game to the likes of Western Kentucky, Akron, and Towson to rank #92 in the nation.  This is a bad matchup for the Hoosiers.  Despite the return of starting middle linebacker Tyler Replogle, who missed last week’s game with a concussion, the Wolverines should be able to have their way.  Quarterback Denard Robinson is the leading rusher in the NCAA, and the only way Indiana should be able to stop him is by bruising his knee after a 30-yard run.  One caveat, though – there’s a strong possibility that running backs Fitzgerald Toussaint (shoulder; 2 carries for 66 yards and 1 TD last week) and Michael Shaw (knee; 44 carries, 256 yards, 5 TDs this year) will miss Saturday’s game.  That leaves sophomore Vincent Smith, redshirt sophomore Michael Cox, and freshman Stephen Hopkins to pick up the slack in the running back rotation.  That shouldn’t matter too much, although those two missing players are big-play threats for Michigan’s offense.
Advantage: Michigan

Pass Offense vs. Indiana Pass Defense
Michigan’s quarterbacks have only been sacked once this year, and the likelihood of Indiana’s front seven catching up to Denard Robinson is low.  The Hoosiers have only mustered four sacks this season in those three games against feeble opponents.  The biggest matchup problem here is 2010 Denard Robinson vs. 2009 Denard Robinson.  If 2010 Denard Robinson keeps up his torrid pace and throws like the 16th most efficient QB in the country, then this should be a clear victory for the Wolverines once again.  I haven’t seen any evidence that Robinson will regress to 2009 form, but his performance so far this season seems too good to be true.  He’s bound to have a bad game at some point, but will it happen against Indiana?  Well . . . probably not.
Advantage: Michigan

Rush Defense vs. Indiana Rush Offense
The Wolverines have done a better job of limiting big runs in 2010.  With eight men consistently in the box, Michigan’s run defense hasn’t been great (#53 in the country, 135.25 yards a game), but big plays have been rare.  Hopefully that can remain true this week, too, because leading rusher Darius Willis (46 carries, 219 yards, 4.8 yards per carry, 2 TDs) had an 85-yard TD against Michigan in 2009, and wideout Tandon Doss had a 25-yard TD in last year’s game, too.  One of the most memorable images from the 2009 season was of Willis outrunning safety Jordan Kovacs and cornerback J.T. Floyd to the endzone.  That was not a happy moment.  The only guy who had a prayer of catching Willis from behind was safety Troy Woolfolk, who’s currently healing from a broken ankle.  Michigan’s secondary is even a bit slower this year, as Floyd and Kovacs are back but Woolfolk’s replacement is Cam Gordon, who gets outrun by 265 lb. tight ends and MAC wide receivers.  Improved play from Michigan’s linebackers – as well as the eight-man front – should be able to stall Willis a little better this year, but there will be some frustrating moments.
Advantage: Indiana

Pass Defense vs. Indiana Pass Offense
This is what scares me.  Bad opponents or not, Indiana averages 304 yards a game through the air (#11 in the country).  Michigan played a couple patsies and Notre Dame, but ranks #105 in the country in pass defense (264 yards a game) and #55 in pass efficiency defense.  Indiana quarterback Ben Chappell threw for 270 yards last year, and he’s supported by some good-sized receivers with decent but not great speed.  Free safety Cameron Gordon has been a liability in pass coverage, and I expect Indiana to test him repeatedly; the Hoosiers would be silly not to try.  Michigan hasn’t shown the ability to shut down a decent passing game, and I don’t think this is the week that they’ll step up.  Michigan fans will just have to pony up and expect some big plays through the air.
Advantage: Indiana

Final Predictions

  • Denard Robinson rushes for 150 yards and 2 touchdowns
  • Ben Chappell increases the team’s passing average by throwing for 305 yards or more
  • Michigan finally gets a big play out of the return game
  • My preseason upset pick will be proven wrong because . . .
  • . . . Michigan will win 45-31


  1. Comments: 21381
    Oct 01, 2010 at 12:49 PM

    Shaw and Fitz are definitely out, which sucks, especially because Shaw is a really good blocker, IMO. I'm eager to see what Cox can do in a semi-leading role (I assume that Vinny will start). I'd prefer to see him start over Smith, though I sincerely doubt that will happen. But, I will say that Smith doesn't make the little mental errors that Cox can't seem to shake (despite having superior physical skills).

    Anyway, I am glad to see you flipping on your preseason pick of an IU upset. Let's keep this train moving!

    Hey, maybe we should hire TRAIN MONKEY to coach special teams?

  2. Comments: 21381
    Oct 01, 2010 at 9:33 PM

    lol basically every week the advantages are the same: michigan gets nod on offense passing/rushing and opponent gets nod on offense passing/rushing.


  3. Comments: 21381
    Oct 01, 2010 at 11:17 PM

    Very nice that you don't think that the defense will lose this game as you mentioned before. Undoubtedly this is because DR is insanely good and IU has no prayer to stop him. And we have a slight prayer to stop Chappell. I actually think the defense outperforms expectations and keeps IU between 20 and 25 pts by forcing an interception and recovering a fumble.

    On another note, word is K Grady may get some reps at RB this game. What's your take on this?

  4. Comments: 21381
    Blue in South Bend
    Oct 01, 2010 at 11:50 PM

    Optimism? Bestill by maize and blue heart…

    Over/Under on missed assignments for Cox. He probably has better physical tools than Smith, but I'm not tremendously comfortable with his grasp of the nuances of the offense (or the full playbook, for that matter).

  5. Comments: 21381
    Oct 02, 2010 at 4:52 AM

    @ Alex 7:17 p.m.

    I'd be pretty impressed if Michigan holds IU to 20-25 points.

    I think Grady offers some quickness that some of our other running backs don't. The thing is, he's not going to break many tackles. So if Michigan is able to open up some holes and handle IU's front, then I'm for it. But I think it should just be a situational sort of thing.

  6. Comments: 21381
    Oct 02, 2010 at 6:38 PM

    I offer a similar commentary on the game over at — though I think the M defense will hold Indiana to 17 points. I think they will come stoked and ready to play.

  7. Comments: 21381
    Oct 02, 2010 at 9:19 PM

    @ Alex Sirota

    Well, it's halftime and Indiana has already scored 21…

You must belogged in to post a comment.